Review: Under the Same Stars – Tim Lott

tim lottIt is 2008, in the middle of the great banking crisis and the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina.  Salinger Nash, an artist based in London, receives a phone call from his brother Carson who has lived in America for most of his adult life, asking him to travel to America where the two of them will go on a road trip to try to track down their father.  This is the essence of Tim Lott’s new novel, Under The Same Stars, his first adult novel since 2009 when he published the highly regarded Rumours of a Hurricane.

The younger brother Salinger is named after the writer J.D. Salinger of Catcher in the Rye fame, and Carson is named after Carson McCullers – two great American writers who specialise in the theme of loneliness. Their father abandoned the two boys  and their mother when they were young and refused to have any further contact with them.  Perhaps the exigencies of the time are reminding them that their father must be very old now and is going to die without seeing how his sons turned out (and don’t we all want to show our parents what happened to us?).

Salinger’s character is imbued with a typically London cynicism which is his defence against disappointment and rejection.  Salinger lives with his girlfriend but the relationship seems to be floundering and perhaps this is time to go to the USA and see what happens when he returns. Carson on the other hand is a born-again Christian, and is relentlessly upbeat, responding to every negative remark with a unrealistically optimistic cliché.  Perhaps both men have adopted personas which in some way protect them from the sense of rejection they acquired as boys when their father left them.

Salinger is not surprised to find that Carson’s has done extremely well in America.  He has a perfect home, a perfect wife and a shiny new Lexus sitting in the driveway.  The car is Carson’s pride and joy and he wipes it clean both inside and out at the end of every day.  Salinger seems to delight in dropping small items of rubbish on the floor knowing that this will irritate his older brother.

As they travel across the American South, the banter between the two men has a cutting edge with childhood rivalries never far below the surface.  The contrast between Carson’s positivity and Salinger’s cynicism leads to endless bickering between them, not only on personal themes but also on the contrasting attitudes between Britons and Americans.  I enjoyed the spat which erupted when Carson erupts at yet another one of Salinger’s cutting remarks about bland, corporate America:

“All this bitching about globalization, standardization, homogenization. Think what England was like before it arrived. What was there before Starbucks? Second-rate greasy spoons where the tea was stewed and the coffee tasted like mud. What was there before McDonald’s? Wimpy Bars. What was there before Gap? Burton. And you’re telling me we’re screwing up the world?”

The Lexus came to a halt. The Holiday Inn sign flickered high at the end of the street. A static jigsaw of traffic held them in its grip.

“1951. That was the golden year. Coming of the malls. Victor Gruen, the first modern mall in Seattle. Model taken up all over the world. Clean, quiet, dry, temperature-controlled. What did we have in Willesden? The high street. What was in the high street? Bakers selling soggy rolls. Butchers selling sausages filled with cardboard and toenails. Fishmongers with three varieties of fish. The Cosy Nook café, the Copper Kettle, the Buttery”.

Tim Lott puts the two brothers through various adventures, not least the theft of the beautiful Lexus.  An unlikely cop helps them out and the brothers travel on by motorbike, enjoying the temporary thrill of living for a few days in a James Dean movie.

American road trip

American road trip

Eventually the brothers arrive at their destination, the small town where their father was last reported to be living.  They do not know his address and have to hunt round various cheap cafés and diners in the hope of spotting him.  I won’t say what happens in the end but it is definitely a suitable ending, despite some reservations about the final resolution which although satisfying seemed a little trite to me.

I read this book while on holiday and it turned out to be a perfect match for my mood.  Light enough to be amusing, but also having enough grit to hold my interest and keep me returning to it as I hovered between promenade benches and open-air cafés.  While my wife read the newspaper I found myself eager to travel the next few miles with the two brothers as they drove along America’s giant freeways and quiet back-roads.  A 4-star read but still very good.

This was not a review copy.

9 thoughts on “Review: Under the Same Stars – Tim Lott

  1. This sounds hilarious … especially the idea that McDonalds and Starbucks has improved cuisine in Britain!
    Methinks it was Elizabeth David. Surely, once rationing was out of the way and people began to cook better at home, and especially when mass tourism began and people enjoyed good food in Europe, they began to demand better in cafes and restaurants at home in the UK!
    In all my recent travels in the UK, I’ve encountered just one eating place that daunted me. The Spouse manfully ate his way through his but not me, I went over the road to the supermarket for some fresh fruit and a muesli bar!


    • Hi Lisa – on the whole it’s not the McDonalds which has improved things to much as the “buy local” movement with an emphasis on locally sourced quality ingredients. However coffee chains have definitely improved the coffee available and in my view provide a quality product. Thanks for the comment


  2. Sounds like an entertaining character study.

    I laughed when I read something that you wrote.

    “Carson on the other hand is a born-again Christian, and is relentlessly upbeat, responding to every negative remark with a unrealistically optimistic cliché.”

    This reminds me of a certain breed of mostly young people who enter the business world. Of course these folks are usually cured of this ailment after a couple of years.


  3. Sounds like a book I would enjoy a lot. I noted that while one brother brags up all the big “improvements” they end up looking in “cheap cafes and diners” those peculiar places that seem to defy corporate cannibalism especially in rural areas which are overlooked by the big chains.

    There’s a wonderful documentary called This is Nowhere that explores the lives of people who drive their huge RVs and trailers around America and then park them in Walmart parking lots. It’s an excellent film but also hilarious in a way. You see these people driving hundreds of miles and then parking outside of these big shops only to dash in to pick up their supplies. They apparently are attracted to the familiarity of the place on their quest to travel America. Bizarre & funny to see people lounging in chairs enjoying the view from a concrete parking lot.


    • Hi Guy – I found an excerpt from the film on YT here. I’d love to see that but can’t find it on Lovefilm or Amazon. It reminds me a little of a documentary a few years ago , GRey Nomads, about retired people who travel round Australia in huge motor homes staying at encampments along the north coast.

      Was it you who once referred to “the Tims” and commented on how you got mixed up with them all. At least three notable British authors called Tim!


  4. Just starting the book really, but my “journey” has been somewhat besmirched by a small yet significant detail in the liner notes where it has the brothers travelling “EAST” from New Orleans through Texas! Last time I rode Amtrak from the Big Easy through to LA, we headed WEST! As I said small thing, but when one is taking on a new read it is enough to distract.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s