Don Quixote Readalong Part 4 – war and peace

Reading two books at a time

I’ve never liked reading more than one book at a time, and so its not been particularly easy to interrupt my current book to return to Don Quixote which I am reading over the course of ten weeks.  However, I soon get back into the tales of the valiant knight and his exploits with his servant Sancho Panza.

This week’s reading in Don Quixote covers pages 276 to 368.  I am reading the book in ten chunks of about 90 pages each, and this is chunk number four.

Untangling a mistaken coupling

This week we read of two pairs of lovers, previously mis-matched, now reorganising themselves so they are in the correct pairs!  Don Quixote has little part in this, it being left to the noble Don Fernando to be persuaded of the rightness of the new arrangements – after all, he was to get the lovely Dorotea who his associates assured him was unequalled among women, humble, beautiful, virtuous and loved him greatly.  Who could resist?

The war against the wineskins

Meanwhile our brave Don Quixote persisted with the belief that he had resolved the amorous confusion by doing battle with two huge wineskins containing about 18 gallons (about 70) litres) of wine believing it to be a giant.

Sancho Panza

The company resolve to carry on with their strategy of deceiving Don Quixote in order to persuade him to travel to his home town where they may be able to cure him of his madness.  However, it is too late in the day to journey on that day, and so all decide to spend another night at the inn.

A traveller arrives at the inn, a Christian who has been travelling in Moorish lands, and with him is a beautiful Moorish woman, Lela Maria.

Is it better to work in an office or to join the army?

However, perhaps the most interesting section in this week’s reading is Don Quixote’s discourse on whether it is better to be a man of letters or a man of arms.  De Cervantes does not hesitate in regaling his readers with the thoughts of Don Quixote on these matters.  And as his audience around the table were military men they apparently approved of his arguments – de Cervantes readers may think otherwise.

In typical contrariwise logic, Don Quixote declares that peace is the true purpose of war, but at least he comes out against the escalation of the arms trade –

Happy were those blessed times that lacked the horrifying fury of the diabolical instuments of artillery, whose inventor, in my opinion, is in hell, receiving the reward for his accursed invention, which allows an ignoble and cowardly hand to take the life of a valiant knight, so that not knowing how it comes, or from where, a stray shot is fired into the courage and spirit that inflame and animate a brave heart.

Alas, in those early days they were just beginning to understand that progress in the technology of war is unstoppable, for gaining an advantage of your enemy is the only way to guarantee victory.  It was about as useless for Don Quixote to protest at the use of artillery as it is to protest today about the use of phosphorous bombs.

The rest of the evening is taken up with the tale of the traveller who had been held captive by the Turks – a topic which must have been close to de Cervantes heart for he himself had been held captive for five years.

Title:  Don Quixote
Author:  Miguel de Cervantes (trans. Edith Grossman)
Publication:  Vintage (2005), paperback, 992 pages
ISBN:  9780099469698

7 thoughts on “Don Quixote Readalong Part 4 – war and peace

  1. Tom, Don Quixote’s remarks on arms and letters are one of my favorite parts also. I believe he returns to the theme later in the novel as well. Since DQ is both a man of arms and a man of letters in his incarnation as a fanatical reader and a knight errant, I like how he is able to argue both sides of the case fairly persuasively at times! Rabelais, if I’m not mistaken, had a very similar complaint about the ungentlemanly nature of artillery warfare in the era. Anyway, interesting post and I love that Sancho Panza image you dug up!


    • Richard – thanks for the comment – I forgot that DQ is of course BOTH a man of was and a man of letters. You have an unusual email address!


  2. sorry bit late reply did’t get chance to get to laptop yesterday ,I m coping by set one day aside for the don usually sunday ,I enjoy part 4 the most so far ,the humour of the skin being slashed and the two tale we come accross ,all the best stu


  3. Pingback: 16 Awesome Retellings Of Classic Literature | Israel

  4. Pingback: 16 Awesome Retellings Of Classic Literature | Travelling Guides and Tips

  5. Pingback: 16 Awesome Retellings Of Classic Literature | Thegnarlytroll

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s